It’s only human to dwell on the one that got away. Especially when the object of your affection didn’t actually go anywhere.

Eight years after Ramsey Lyons and her financier husband moved from Baltimore to Pittsburgh, they still couldn’t get a house they’d considered buying out of their heads. A redbrick Tudor that dates back to Pittsburgh’s golden age of industrialists, the fortresslike property was one of the Steel City’s few remaining marquee historical houses. But it needed a good deal of work, more than the couple—with two children then under two—felt up for at the time.

in the front hall, the walls are covered in grass cloth with blue trim, an antique console with lamps and a mirror behind it face a fireplace with a painted patterned wood plank floor
In the entry, the walls are sheathed in Phillip Jeffries grass cloth, and the oak floor was hand-painted by Jon Gluck in a graphic design. The console is from Mark Evers Antiques, the mirror is from Bunny Williams Home, and lamps are by Christopher Spitzmiller.
Nicole Franzen

Still, they never forgot the house. When they passed it a few years later while driving to a son’s friend’s birthday party, they knew it was time. Lyons rang up a local real-estate agent and issued a challenge: Persuade the older couple who’d been quick to take it off the market to sell it, while also finding a buyer for the Lyonses’ home—all in the space of two weeks. Mission accomplished, the next challenge was on her: Take a 12,000-​square-foot house whose baronial vibe conjures an Agatha Christie murder mystery and transform it into a modern home for a family with two kids (now tweens), a pair of dogs, and two pet rabbits.

Design has always been in Lyons’s blood. During her first decade out of college, while working ungodly hours as an investment banker in New York, she would unwind at the townhouse her friends were in the process of decorating. “I’d go over and rearrange fabric swatches in their basement,” she recalls. “That was my happy place.” Once she’d settled into Pittsburgh, she started to work as a designer. By the time she and her husband bought this house, she had a dream team of artisans and builders on her speed dial.

in the tv room with pink walls is an upholstered sofa, two chairs with carved wood arms and cocktail tables, and in the background are blue chairs and a large artwork with butterflies
The designer’s pet rabbits rest on a custom sofa in the second-floor TV room. The artwork is by Hunt Slonem.
Nicole Franzen

Built in 1907 as a Victorian, the home was expanded and extensively remodeled in the Tudor style in the 1920s. Confronted with heavy window treatments and an eyesore of a stair hall, Lyons considered ripping everything out and starting from scratch. But the idea of scrapping the original craftsmanship was unthinkable. So she decided to do something much harder: bring it all up to date in a respectful and innovative way. “What Ramsey did is completely outside of the box,” says Jon Gluck, the decorative painter she tapped to instill a new sense of lightness. “It’s an old-world estate home entirely reimagined to be timeless.”

Using limewash and tinted wax, Gluck transformed the quartersawn oak panels that cradled the first-floor walls into surfaces you’d never associate with a fusty library at a private club. Original leaded windows and stained-glass fixtures were restored and installed, sometimes in new spaces. Room by room, Lyons dialed down the darkness and readied the structure for another century’s use. “She’s a designer, but she’s also the custodian of this house,” says David Duncan, the owner of the eponymous New York studio from which she sourced vintage pieces and lighting fixtures of his design.

“All my kids’ friends want to be here all of the time.”

Today, the home’s traditional but fresh spirit is in keeping with Pittsburgh’s history as the original epicenter of American disruptors. (If Succession was set at the turn of the 20th century, it would have taken place here among the city’s railroad and steel magnates.) Take the mudroom, a testament to Lyons’s commitment to low-key livability. The heavily trafficked corridor features a wall mural that Gluck based on a 1933 painting by Japanese artist Zenzaburo Kojima. He imagined a treescape with an underwater feel, where jellyfish-like forms float in a palette of blues and greens that, along with purple, pervade the rest of the home.

in the family room children sit on a fabric covered banquette near upholstered chairs and a cocktail table, and there are bookshelves flanking a fireplace with a damien hirst artwork above it
Lyons’s children sit on a custom banquette in a Groundworks print. The dining and cocktail tables are from Aronson Woodworks, the armchairs (rear) from Bunny Williams Home, the blue chairs from Coley Home, and the vintage chair fabric is from Tilton Fenwick. The artwork is by Damien Hirst.
Nicole Franzen

The mix of contemporary and vintage furniture in the house undergirds its adventurous spirit. There are Frances Adler Elkins loop chairs and Cloud chairs by Art Deco designers Harry and Lou Epstein alongside newer pieces from Chairish. Contemporary paintings by artists such as Hunt Slonem and Damien Hirst were selected by an exclusive acquisition committee. “Everybody in the family gets a vote,” Lyons says. “The kids always steer us toward more colorful pieces.”

Three years and counting into the project (a small team of woodworkers is still toiling away in the basement), she has pulled off a near impossible feat: Preserve a historic home but make it fun. Craftsmanship and pedigree are disentangled here from pomp and formality. “All my kids’ friends want to be here all of the time,” Lyons says. “I’ve made a space that is about joy.”

Tour Ramsey Lyons’s Transformed Pittsburgh Landmark Home
living room with two sitting areas with upholstered sofa and chairs, carved wood wall paneling, decorative plaster ceiling, multiple paned windows, and a deep blue artwork above the fireplace

Styled by Howard Christian

march 2022 cover elle decor

This story originally appeared in the April 2022 issue of ELLE DECOR. SUBSCRIBE